AI Photo Editing Software: 2024 Deep Dive Comparison

Tired of spending hours meticulously editing photos? Artificial intelligence (AI) is revolutionizing image editing, offering powerful features that automate complex tasks and unlock creative possibilities previously only accessible to seasoned professionals. This in-depth comparison breaks down the leading AI photo editing software options, helping you choose the right tool to enhance your workflow and elevate your images, whether you are a professional photographer, a social media enthusiast, or simply someone who loves taking pictures. This guide analyzes specific features, pricing plans, and real-world use cases to give you a clear picture of what each platform offers.

What to Look For in AI Photo Editing Software

Before diving into specific tools, let’s clarify the key features to consider:

• AI-Powered Enhancements: This includes features like automatic color correction, smart sharpening, noise reduction, and detail enhancement. Look for software that learns from your edits and adapts its algorithms to your style.
• Object Removal/Addition: The ability to seamlessly remove unwanted objects or add new elements to your photos. The quality of the removal and ease of use here are critical.
• Style Transfer: Apply different artistic styles to your photos using AI algorithms inspired by famous artists or custom presets.
• Portrait Enhancement: Features specifically designed for portraits, such as skin smoothing, eye enhancement, and teeth whitening.
• Upscaling: Increase the resolution of your photos without significant quality loss. Useful for old photos or images intended for large prints.
• Sky Replacement: Magically replace dull skies with dramatic and visually appealing alternatives.
• RAW Processing: Support for RAW image formats, which offer greater flexibility and detail compared to JPEGs.
• Ease of Use: An intuitive interface is critical for efficient workflow. Some AI tools prioritize simplicity, while others offer more advanced controls.
• Integration: Compatibility with other software you use, such as Adobe Photoshop or Lightroom. Plugins can streamline your editing process.
• Pricing: Consider the pricing models, including subscription fees, one-time purchases, and free trial options.

Luminar Neo: The AI-Driven All-In-One Editor

Luminar Neo by Skylum is a formidable contender in the AI photo editing space. It aims to be a complete solution, offering a range of AI-powered tools combined with a traditional photo editing workflow.

Key Features:

• Sky Replacement AI: This feature is renowned in the industry. Luminar Neo excels at automatically detecting and replacing skies, complete with realistic reflections in water.
• Portrait Enhancer AI: Automatically enhances portraits with skin smoothing, blemish removal, and eye enhancement. It avoids the overly-processed look that some portrait tools produce and handles diverse skin tones well.
• Erase Tool: Intelligently removes unwanted objects with ease. It analyzes the surrounding area and fills the space seamlessly, often outperforming Photoshop’s content-aware fill for basic tasks.
• Relight AI: Adjusts the lighting in your scene based on depth mapping. You can brighten or darken specific areas without affecting the entire image.
• Face AI: Corrects facial imperfections and enhances facial features.
• Body AI: Reshape bodies in photos. (Controversial feature, use responsibly!)
• Noiseless AI: Reduces noise in photos with impressive results, particularly in low-light situations.
• Upscale AI: Increase the resolution of images without significant pixelation.
• GenErase: Precisely erases unwanted elements.
• GenSwap: Replace specific areas with AI-generated objects.

Luminar Neo integrates seamlessly as a plugin for Adobe Photoshop and Lightroom. This is useful if you’re heavily invested in the Adobe ecosystem but want to use Luminar Neo’s AI features.

Pricing:

• Subscription: Plans vary, ranging from monthly subscriptions to annual plans. The Explorer plan starts at around $14.95/month billed monthly or $59/year annualy.
• Lifetime License: Offers a one-time purchase option for perpetual access to the software. This is a good choice if you prefer not to pay subscription fees. This currently runs at about $199.

Pros:

• Excellent AI-powered tools for enhancing photos quickly.
• Sky Replacement and Portrait Enhancer AI are standouts.
• Relatively user-friendly interface.
• Plugin support for Photoshop and Lightroom.
• Lifetime license option available.

Cons:

• Can be resource-intensive, especially with complex edits.
• Some AI features might produce unrealistic results if overused.
• Subscription model might not appeal to all users, however a lifetime plan is available.
• Updates can sometimes introduce bugs, requiring subsequent patches.

Adobe Photoshop: The Industry Standard with AI Integration

Adobe Photoshop remains the industry standard for professional photo editing. While traditionally reliant on manual techniques, Adobe has been aggressively integrating AI features powered by their Sensei AI engine to enhance its capabilities.

Key Features:

• Generative Fill: A game-changer that lets you add, extend, or remove content from your images using text prompts. It seamlessly blends the new content with the existing image, taking into account lighting, perspective, and style.
• Neural Filters: A collection of AI-powered filters that automate complex tasks, such as skin smoothing, style transfer, and smart portrait adjustments. The Smart Portrait filter, for example, lets you change a person’s age, gaze direction, or even facial expression.
• Object Selection Tool: Improved with AI, this tool precisely selects objects in your images, making it easier to isolate and edit them.
• Sky Replacement: While Luminar Neo’s sky replacement is more automated, Photoshop’s version offers greater manual control.
• Super Resolution: Increases the resolution of your images while preserving details.

Pricing:

• Subscription-Based: Photoshop is available as part of the Adobe Creative Cloud. A single app subscription costs around $22.99 per month. The Photography plan (Photoshop + Lightroom) is a popular choice for photographers and comes in at around $11.99 per month.
• All Apps Plan: Access to all Adobe Creative Cloud apps, including Photoshop, Lightroom, Illustrator, and Premiere Pro. This plan costs around $59.99 per month.

Pros:

• Industry-standard software with extensive capabilities.
• Powerful AI features, especially Generative Fill and Neural Filters.
• Precise object selection and masking.
• Vast ecosystem of plugins and tutorials.
• Excellent RAW processing.

Cons:

• Steep learning curve for beginners.
• Subscription-based pricing only.
• Resource-intensive software that requires a powerful computer.
• Can be overwhelming with its numerous features.

Photolemur 3: Simple AI Photo Enhancement

Photolemur 3, also from Skylum (the makers of Luminar), is designed for users who want quick and effortless photo enhancements. It automatically analyzes your photos and applies a series of adjustments to improve their overall look. While not as feature-rich as Luminar Neo or Photoshop, it excels at simplifying the editing process.

Key Features:

• Automatic AI Analysis: Analyzes your photos and automatically applies adjustments to color, exposure, and contrast.
• Face Finish Technology: Automatically smooths skin, removes blemishes, and enhances eyes.
• Sky Enhancement: Improves the appearance of skies, making them more vibrant and dramatic.
• Smart Dehaze: Reduces haze and fog in your photos.
• One-Click Enhancement: Applies all adjustments with a single click.

Pricing:

• One-Time Purchase: Photolemur 3 is available for a one-time purchase, making it an attractive option for users who prefer to avoid subscriptions. Expect to pay about $49.

Pros:

• Extremely easy to use, ideal for beginners.
• Automatic AI enhancements save time.
• One-time purchase option.

Cons:

• Limited manual control over adjustments.
• Fewer features compared to Luminar Neo or Photoshop.
• May not be suitable for professional photographers who require precise control.
• Discontinued product – support may become an issue.

PhotoDirector 365: A Balanced Approach

PhotoDirector 365 from CyberLink offers a blend of traditional photo editing tools and AI-powered features. It’s designed to be user-friendly while still providing a wide range of capabilities.

Key Features:

• AI Sky Replacement: Similar to Luminar Neo, PhotoDirector 365 lets you replace skies with realistic alternatives.
• AI Dehaze: Reduces haze and fog in your photos.
• AI Style Transfer: Applies different artistic styles to your photos.
• AI Face Swap: Swaps faces between photos. (Another feature to use responsibly!)
• AI Photo Enhancement: Automatically adjusts color, exposure, and contrast.
• Content-Aware Removal: Removes unwanted objects from your photos.
• Object Selection Accurately select objects with AI technology, allowing for specific enhancements.

Pricing:

• Subscription: PhotoDirector 365 is available through subscription, costing about $54.99/year. The subscription model ensures that you have access to the latest updates and features.
• Perpetual License: While primarily focusing on the subscription model, CyberLink periodically offers standalone versions of PhotoDirector with a lifetime license.

Pros:

• User-friendly interface.
• Good balance of AI and traditional editing tools.
• Affordable subscription price.
• Regular feature updates.

Cons:

• Subscription model might not appeal to all users.
• Some AI features might not be as advanced as those in Luminar Neo or Photoshop.
• Some reports of performance issues on older hardware.

ON1 Photo RAW: Comprehensive RAW Processing with AI

ON1 Photo RAW is a comprehensive photo editor with a focus on RAW processing and non-destructive adjustments. It incorporates AI features to enhance its workflow and image quality.

Key Features:

• AI Match: Automatically matches the colors and tones of different photos.
• AI Auto Tone: Automatically adjusts the exposure and contrast of your photos.
• AI Portrait: Automatically retouches and enhances portraits.
• NoNoise AI: Quickly removes noise and recovers details in noisy photos.
• Sky Swap AI: Replace or enhance skies easily.
• Tack Sharp AI: Sharpen and recover blurry photos.

Pricing:

• One-Time Purchase: ON1 Photo RAW is available as a one-time purchase with periodic paid upgrades.
• Subscription: ON1 also offers a subscription-based model that includes access to all of their apps and updates.
• Expect to pay around $7.99/month or a one-time payment of $99.99.

Pros:

• Excellent RAW processing capabilities.
• Non-destructive editing workflow.
• Availability of both one-time purchase and subscription options.
• Focuses on professional photography needs.

Cons:

• Interface can be overwhelming for beginners.
• Can be resource-intensive.
• Some AI features might require refinement.

Comparison Table: AI Photo Editing Software

Software	Key AI Features	Pricing Model	Best For
Luminar Neo	Sky Replacement AI, Portrait Enhancer AI, Erase Tool,Relight AI, Face AI, Body AI, GenErase, GenSwap.	Subscription or Lifetime License	Users who want quick, AI-powered edits
Adobe Photoshop	Generative Fill, Neural Filters, Object Selection Tool, Sky Replacement, Super Resolution	Subscription	Professionals who need comprehensive editing tools
Photolemur 3	Automatic AI Analysis, Face Finish Technology, Sky Enhancement, Smart Dehaze	One-Time Purchase	Beginners who want simple photo enhancements
PhotoDirector 365	AI Sky Replacement, AI Dehaze, AI Style Transfer, AI Face Swap, AI Photo Enhancement	Subscription	Users who want a balance of AI and traditional tools
ON1 Photo RAW	AI Match, AI Auto Tone, AI Portrait, NoNoise AI, Tack Sharp AI	One-Time Purchase/Subscription	Professional photographers who need RAW processing with AI

Analyzing specific AI functionalities: Detailed Feature Breakdown

Now, let’s drill down into specific AI functions and see how the various applications stack up, focusing on performance, ease of use, and quality of results.

AI-Powered Noise reduction: Noiseless AI (Luminar Neo) vs. NoNoise AI (ON1 Photo RAW)

Both Luminar Neo and ON1 Photo RAW offer dedicated AI-powered noise reduction. In tests, Luminar Neo’s Noiseless AI demonstrates a slightly better capability at removing noise while retaining finer details. ON1’s implementation is good, but at aggressive settings, it can sometimes result in a more “smoothed-over” look. Luminar also provides more granular control over the noise reduction process, allowing users to fine-tune the settings to achieve optimal results. However, ON1 wins in the area of workflow. ON1 also offers additional sharpness tools right next to the Noiseless AI slider, which makes for convenient and rapid adjustments.

Verdict: Luminar Neo slightly edges out ON1 in noise reduction quality, but ON1 offers some adjacent tool benefits.

Sky Replacement: Luminar Neo vs. Photoshop

Luminar Neo’s Sky Replacement AI is arguably its standout feature. It’s incredibly easy to use: simply choose a sky, and the AI automatically detects the existing sky, creates a convincing mask, and applies realistic reflections and lighting adjustments. Photoshop, on the other hand, provides more control but requires more manual work. You need to select the sky manually, refine the mask, and adjust the colors and lighting to match the new sky. For speed and ease of use, Luminar Neo is the clear winner. But for ultimate control and precision, Photoshop is better.

Verdict: Luminar Neo for speed and simplicity; Photoshop for control and precision.

AI-Powered Portrait Enhancement: Luminar Neo vs. Photoshop Neural Filters

Both Luminar Neo and Photoshop (via Neural Filters) offer AI-powered portrait enhancement tools. Luminar’s Portrait Enhancer AI automatically smooths skin, removes blemishes, and enhances eyes. The results are generally very good, but there is a risk of the “plastic skin” look if overused. Photoshop’s Neural Filters, particularly the Smart Portrait filter, offer more granular control over various aspects of the portrait, such as age, gaze direction, and facial expression. This allows for much more subtle and realistic enhancements but also requires more skill and time. What’s more, the Smart Portrait filter resides in a destructive workflow! This is a major detractor in the flexibility Photoshop provides.

Verdict: Luminar Neo for quick and easy enhancements; Photoshop (Neural Filters) for precise and nuanced adjustments.

Generative Fill: Photoshop vs. Luminar Neo (GenErase/GenSwap)

Photoshop’s Generative Fill stands out in its ability to seamlessly add, extend, or remove content from your images. The results can be incredibly realistic, thanks to Adobe’s advanced AI algorithms. Luminar Neo offers similar functionality via GenErase and GenSwap. Generative fill has the edge here. GenErase and GenSwap are a good offering, but are not quite as good or refined as Generative Fill.

Verdict: Photoshop’s Generative Fill provides more refined and realistic results for complex content manipulation.

Who Should Use Which AI Photo Editor?

• Luminar Neo: Ideal for photographers and enthusiasts who want quick, AI-powered edits with minimal effort. Its Sky Replacement and Portrait Enhancer AI are particularly impressive. Perfect for social media users and those who want to enhance their photos without spending hours on editing.
• Adobe Photoshop: Best suited for professional photographers, graphic designers, and anyone who needs comprehensive editing tools and precise control over their images. Its AI features, such as Generative Fill and Neural Filters, enhance its already powerful capabilities.
• Photolemur 3: Perfect for beginners and casual users who want simple, one-click photo enhancements. However, its limited features and now-discontinued status make it a less compelling choice compared to other options.
• PhotoDirector 365: A good option for users who want a balance of AI and traditional editing tools. Its user-friendly interface and affordable subscription price make it accessible to a wide range of users.
• ON1 Photo RAW: Perfect for professional photographers focusing using the RAW workflow. The perpetual license option makes it appealing to users who do not want to subscribe.

Final Verdict

The best AI photo editing software depends on your specific needs and skill level. If you prioritize speed and ease of use, Luminar Neo and Photolemur 3 are excellent choices. If you need comprehensive editing tools and precise control, Adobe Photoshop remains the industry standard. PhotoDirector 365 offers a balanced approach, while ON1 Photo RAW excels in RAW processing. Each option has its strengths and weaknesses, so carefully consider your requirements before making a decision. I personally recommend beginners start out with Photolemur (if you can still find a license), move onto Luminar Neo, and then if you need more control from there, Adobe Photoshop.

Ready to explore the power of AI photo editing? Check out our recommended affiliate links here to learn more and start your free trial!